Brothers Pizza McSherrystown Reviews

When the order showed up, my first thought was that everything looked solid. The pizza was hot and looked good, but I did notice they missed one of the toppings I asked for. Not a huge deal though — it still tasted fine and I’d probably order again.

The people there were really nice. I called with a quick question about my order, and the guy I spoke with was patient and helpful. That said, I was a little annoyed because some of the communication about the order wasn’t very clear, so I had to call in the first place. When I went to pick it up, everyone was friendly and the whole thing ended up being easy overall

The food was alright, nothing amazing but not bad. What really bothered me was how the place looked when I walked in. The tables felt sticky, and the floor definitely needed to be cleaned. It just didn’t give a great first impression. I also mentioned it afterward and never got any kind of follow-up, which was disappointing.

I’ve ordered from here a few times now, and every single time the pizza gets to my door faster than I expect. Like, I’ll place the order and think I have plenty of time to get settled, grab a drink, maybe put something on TV, and then suddenly it’s already here. The best part is it doesn’t arrive lukewarm or like it’s been sitting around either, it’s still hot, the cheese is still melty, and it actually feels fresh. I’m really happy with it because fast delivery is great, but fast delivery with hot pizza is what really makes it worth ordering again.

The prices are fair and the pizza was definitely worth the money. We got plenty of food and everything tasted fresh, so no complaints there. the only frustrating part was how long we had to wait, but once the food came out, it was good enough that I’d still go back.

I gave the pizza a try, but it was bland. Nothing terrible, just not much flavor going on, and I probably wouldn’t order it again.